自動化之前點樣量度 baseline?先知慳咗幾多時間
簡單答:自動化之前,用一至兩個星期記錄四樣數字:每月做幾多件、每件用幾耐、出錯幾多次、由收到到完成等幾耐。呢個就係 baseline。自動化之後用同一個方法再記一次,兩次一比,就知道實際慳返幾多時間同減少咗幾多錯,唔使靠「感覺好似快咗」。
點解一定要有 baseline
- 知道值唔值:慳咗幾多個鐘、少咗幾多錯,先計到回本期。
- 決定下一步:第一條流程有數據證明有效,擴到第二條先有理據。
- 發現問題:如果自動化之後反而要花更多時間核對,數字會即刻話你知。
冇 baseline 係 AI 自動化項目最常見嘅失敗原因之一,詳見《AI 自動化項目失敗嘅 5 個常見原因》。
要量度嘅四樣數字
- 數量:每月處理幾多件,例如收據幾多張、會議幾多個、同事幾多個要計糧。
- 每件用時:由開始做到完成,每件平均幾多分鐘。包埋搵資料、輸入、檢查。
- 出錯次數:每月有幾多件要返工、改錯,或者被會計、客人指出問題。
- 等候時間:由收到(例如收據交上嚟)到處理完要等幾耐。呢個唔係工時,但影響老闆幾時睇到數。
點樣記錄:一張簡單表就夠
開一張 Excel 或者 Google Sheets,每做一件記一行:
- 日期
- 邊個做
- 開始同完成時間(或者直接寫用咗幾多分鐘)
- 有冇出錯、要唔要返工
- 備註(例如「手寫單,睇唔清」)
記一至兩個星期就夠,唔使記成個月。重點係記嗰段時間要係平常日子,避開年結、節日呢啲特別繁忙或者特別淡嘅時候。
點樣計:一個例子
以下係假設數字,用嚟示範點計:
- 每月 300 張收據,每張平均 2 分鐘 → 每月 600 分鐘,即 10 個鐘
- 每月約 15 張要返工,每張再用 5 分鐘 → 每月多 75 分鐘
- baseline 合共:每月約 11 個鐘
自動化之後,同事只需要核對被標記嘅單,同樣用記錄表量度,例如變成每月 2 個鐘,咁每月就慳返約 9 個鐘。再乘以同事嘅時薪,就知道每月慳返幾多錢,同埋項目幾耐回本。
記住:自動化之後新增嘅工作,例如核對被標記嘅項目,一定要計埋,先係公平比較。
常見錯誤
- 憑記憶估:「大概每張一分鐘啦」通常會低估,因為冇計搵資料同改錯嘅時間。
- 前後量度方法唔同:之前計埋檢查時間,之後唔計,結果就唔準。
- 揀錯時段:喺特別淡嘅月份量 baseline,自動化嘅效果會被低估。
- 淨係計時間:出錯少咗、老闆早咗睇到數,都係效果,要一齊記低。
自己做最常卡喺邊?
- 同事覺得記錄麻煩,記咗兩日就冇再記
- 唔知「一件」點樣定義,例如一張單定一個月嘅數
- 自動化之後唔知點樣用同一方法再量,數字比較唔到
- 有數字但唔知點樣計成錢同回本期
以上任何一樣卡住咗,都可以搵我哋。簽約前免費諮詢,我哋會直接話你知要做乜、大概幾錢。
我哋可以點幫你
MuduoPro 嘅 AI 流程自動化每個項目都由量度 baseline 開始:單一流程 HK$5,000 起,最快 2 日交付;多流程 HK$15,000 起,包項目前後成效量度同同事培訓 1 次;部門方案 HK$30,000 起,包進度儀表板同交付後 3 個月跟進。實際例子可以睇《收據影相自動入數》同《打卡出糧自動化》。所有套餐可以睇套餐同價錢,或者直接同我哋傾一次,簽約前免費諮詢。
How to measure a baseline before automating, so you know what you saved
The short answer: before automating, spend one or two weeks recording four numbers: how many items you handle a month, how long each takes, how many errors occur, and how long items wait from arrival to completion. That is your baseline. After automating, record them again the same way. Comparing the two shows exactly how much time and how many errors you saved, instead of relying on "it feels faster".
Why you need a baseline
- To know whether it was worth it: hours saved and errors avoided let you work out the payback period.
- To decide what is next: data showing the first workflow works is the case for automating a second.
- To spot problems: if checking the automated output takes more time than before, the numbers tell you straight away.
Having no baseline is one of the most common reasons AI automation projects fail; see 5 common reasons AI automation projects fail.
The four numbers to measure
- Volume: how many items a month, such as receipts, meetings, or staff to pay.
- Time per item: average minutes from start to finish, including finding information, entering it and checking it.
- Errors: how many items a month need redoing or correcting, or are flagged by your accountant or customers.
- Waiting time: how long from arrival (for example, a receipt handed in) to completion. It is not working time, but it affects when the owner sees the figures.
How to record it: one simple sheet
Open an Excel or Google Sheets file and add one row for each item handled:
- Date
- Who did it
- Start and finish time (or simply the minutes taken)
- Whether there was an error or rework
- Notes (for example, "handwritten receipt, hard to read")
One or two weeks is enough; you do not need a whole month. What matters is that the period is a normal one, avoiding year-end, holidays and other unusually busy or quiet times.
How to calculate it: an example
The figures below are hypothetical, to show the method:
- 300 receipts a month at 2 minutes each → 600 minutes, or 10 hours a month
- About 15 need rework each month, at 5 more minutes each → 75 more minutes a month
- Baseline total: about 11 hours a month
After automating, staff only check the flagged receipts. Measured with the same sheet, that might come to 2 hours a month, saving about 9 hours a month. Multiply by the colleague's hourly cost to see the monthly saving and how long the project takes to pay for itself.
Remember to include any new work the automation creates, such as checking flagged items; otherwise the comparison is not fair.
Common mistakes
- Estimating from memory: "about a minute each" usually underestimates, because it leaves out finding information and fixing mistakes.
- Measuring differently before and after: including checking time before but not after makes the result meaningless.
- Choosing the wrong period: measuring the baseline in an unusually quiet month understates the benefit.
- Counting only time: fewer errors and figures reaching the owner sooner are results too; record them as well.
Where do people usually get stuck?
- Staff find logging tedious and stop after two days
- Not knowing how to define "one item", such as one receipt or one month's accounts
- Not knowing how to measure the same way after automating, so the numbers cannot be compared
- Having the numbers but not knowing how to turn them into money and a payback period
If any of these is where you are stuck, talk to us. Consultation before signing is free, and we will tell you plainly what needs doing and roughly what it costs.
How we can help
Every MuduoPro AI workflow automation project starts by measuring the baseline: single workflows from HK$5,000, delivered in as little as 2 days; multiple workflows from HK$15,000, including before-and-after measurement and one staff training session; department plans from HK$30,000, with a progress dashboard and 3 months of follow-up after delivery. For worked examples, see Turning receipt photos into accounts automatically and Automating payroll from timesheets. See all packages and pricing, or talk to us: consultation before signing is free.